On October 13, 2026, a federal judge in Seattle sent a Washington wage and hour class action back to King County Superior Court, holding that the employer failed to prove the case belonged in federal court. The ruling is procedural, but it matters: employers frequently remove class actions to federal court in hopes of a friendlier forum, and this order shows the math has to actually work.
Background
The plaintiff alleges that she and other Washington workers were allegedly required to work through or delay meal and rest breaks without compensation, allegedly worked off the clock, and allegedly were not paid overtime. She filed in state court on behalf of a class of at least 100 current and former employees. The employer denies the allegations.
The employer removed the case to federal court under diversity jurisdiction, which requires that the named plaintiff’s individual claims exceed $75,000. It initially valued her claims at over $100,000. After she moved to remand, the employer’s own estimate dropped to roughly $48,000 to $55,000 in damages, plus more than $41,000 in attorney fees. The plaintiff estimated the total at about $28,000.
What the Court Decided
Since both sides agreed damages alone fell short of $75,000, the case turned on attorney fees. The court rejected the employer’s two theories:
- Half of a prior class fee award is not the plaintiff’s share. The employer pointed to a fee award in an earlier class case handled by plaintiff’s counsel and argued half of it should be attributed to the named plaintiff. The court found no authority for a 50% allocation. Following other Western District decisions, it divided the award across the 100 putative class members, yielding far less per plaintiff.
- A “100 hours at $700” assumption needs evidence. The employer alternatively argued counsel would spend at least 100 hours on an individual case. It submitted no declarations or data to support that, and the court declined to credit an unsupported assumption.
With the employer’s best damages number short of the $75,000 threshold and no credible fee estimate to close the gap, the case was remanded.
Why It Matters
Washington state courts are generally viewed as a favorable forum for employees in wage and hour cases, and employers know it. Removal to federal court is a common first move. This order reinforces three points: the employer bears the burden of proving the amount in controversy with real evidence once challenged; in a traditional diversity removal, class members’ claims cannot be aggregated and the named plaintiff must independently clear $75,000; and attorney fees are allocated pro rata across the class, not loaded onto one plaintiff. For a typical hourly worker whose individual unpaid-break and overtime claims total tens of thousands of dollars, that makes federal removal difficult to sustain.
Talk to a Washington Wage and Hour Attorney
Crosner Legal represents employees in wage and hour class actions across Washington, Oregon, California, and Illinois. If you believe you were denied meal or rest breaks, worked off the clock, or were not paid overtime, contact us at (866) 276-7637 or through our website for a free and confidential case evaluation.
This post is attorney advertising and is provided for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. The allegations described are allegations only; the defendant denies them, and the order addresses jurisdiction, not the merits. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.; the defendant denies them, and no court has ruled on the merits. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
